Lionbridge Machine Translation Tracker

The longest-standing measurement of the leading Machine Translation engines — and now several generative AI models — will help you choose the best automated translation option to meet your needs.

TALK TO US

Comparing Four Machine Translation Deployment Strategies

Machine Translation (MT) has been around for decades and has evolved exponentially in recent years. As companies produce ever-growing amounts of content in different languages, they see MT — and now emergent generative AI (GenAI) technology — as an opportunity to extend their reach in an increasingly globalized world.

Companies seeking automated translation solutions may select one of the following four basic strategies. The decision will influence which automation tool they want to implement.

Public MT

This strategy includes services like Google Translate or Bing Translator. Such services are readily available at no cost. However, the strategy’s shortcomings are its lack of security and quality issues in some situations, as engines have not been trained for specific domains or particular use cases.

On-Premises MT

This strategy requires a company to deploy an MT server in its IT environment. While this is the most secure option, it comes at a significant cost, is complex to deploy and manage, and requires ongoing maintenance. Importantly, this strategy often produces suboptimal MT output across multiple language pairs or content types.

Cloud MT

This strategy works like the public MT option because it is also hosted in the cloud. However, unlike public MT, it creates a company-dedicated instance. Any data provided to the service is tightly secured and not shared with third parties. It delivers additional capabilities around terminology customization and has other benefits. However, it can result in vendor lock-in and less-than-optimal MT quality across multiple language pairs.

Best-of-Breed MT

This strategy involves a single platform that allows companies to leverage multiple MT and GenAI engines. It provides a single layer of terminology customization, an easy-to-manage interface, and the ability to choose the best option for different language pairs, industries or domains, and types of content.

Want to learn more about Machine Translation terminology and the different types of automated translation technologies? Check out our blog, Machine Translation in Translation.

Which Automated Translation Engine Is Best?

There’s no simple answer.

When choosing among the many available automated translation systems, it’s important to note that some MT engines are trained to address a specific function or domain. If your needs don’t align with that purpose, the engine may perform sub-optimally, no matter how advanced it is.

Identify why you are using automated translations to determine the most suitable option. If you want an MT engine for general use, it may be appropriate to use Google Translate or Bing Translator. You may achieve better results using a different tool if you seek MT services for a specific language or domain.

Lionbridge is an expert in these technologies. In addition to having more than two decades of MT experience, we have gathered a large volume of linguistic and quality data about MT technology. Lionbridge’s Machine Translation Tracker analyzes the performance of the top five MT engines and several GenAI models. We publish the results periodically to help you understand how these tools perform, depending on the content’s domain and the language pairs used.

Check out our findings below. The results — which are everchanging — can give you an idea of which options are right for you.

Evaluating Overall MT Performance

Time

Chart 1: Comparison of the average quality of top MT engines and several GenAI models for German, Russian, Spanish, and Chinese. Many factors influence the performance of MT engines and GenAI models. These factors include the quality of the source content, the combination of source and target languages, the subject matter, and whether the MT engine was trained. In the overall quality comparison, neural MT engines primarily outperform GenAI models, though the GenAI models perform respectably. This finding is especially true for GPT-4, which is more advanced than the other GenAI models we track.

Per Language Pair Quality

Choose German, Spanish, Russian, or Chinese in the drop-down menu.

Time

Chart 2: Comparison of the average quality of top MT engines and several GenAI models for specific language pairs.

Per Domain Performance

Select Domain/Subject Matter in the drop-down menu.

Time

Chart 3: Comparison of the average quality of top MT engines and several GenAI models for a specific domain.

Lionbridge Machine Translation Tracker Methodology

Lionbridge uses the inverse edit distance as a scoring method. The edit distance measures the number of characters (for Asian languages) or words (for Western languages) that need to be changed by a human post-editor before it achieves the quality level produced by a human translator. The higher the metric, the better the quality.

Additional Details About Lionbridge’s Methodology:

We routinely assess the performance of Machine Translation engines and GenAI models, making our findings public periodically.
We provide the data for illustrative purposes; each case should be treated and assessed individually.
We generate this report based on source data preselected by Lionbridge’s Machine Translation teams. The same source data is submitted to every MT engine / GenAI model and language pair each time, making comparisons between the tools possible.
We do not use customer data to generate the report.

Lionbridge Expert Commentary

Navigating the rapid evolution of the MT and generative AI paradigms can be overwhelming. That’s where our team of seasoned experts comes in. They delve into the intricacies of these technologies daily, periodically sharing their insightful perspectives and thought-provoking analyses across a wide range of topics to our interested readers.

Whether you’re just starting your MT/GenAI journey or are a veteran user of automated translations, the Lionbridge expert commentary will deepen your understanding of these automated translation technologies. Your newly gained insight can help you make strategic business decisions, leading to more efficient translations, the ability to translate more content, and substantial cost-saving benefits.

Access the Commentaries

Get Smarter About Automated Translation

Review some of the most engaging content.

Smart MT™: Machine Translation for the Digital Age

Find out how to leverage MT to offer digital experiences in local languages, achieve better customer satisfaction ratings, and excel in global markets.

LEARN MORE

Lionbridge Language Cloud™: Is Machine Translation Getting Better?

The demand for multilingual content is greater than ever. Find out how the Lionbridge Language Cloud™ automates translation and helps you leverage MT at scale to free you to focus on business growth.

LEARN MORE

How Lionbridge’s Automated Solution Enabled the Le Monde Newspaper to Boost Its Subscriber Count

When iconic French newsgroup Le Monde released its English service, Le Monde, in English, it needed a translation solution that could handle the complexities of the 24-hour news cycle. Using Lionbridge’s Machine Translation solution Smart MT as part of the Lionbridge Language Cloud, Le Monde was able to slash translation turnaround time, cover the French presidential election, and attract thousands of new subscribers to their service.

LEARN MORE

Know the difference between MT and NMT? Can you define MTPE or hybrid MT engine? Click the image below to view key terms and their meanings to understand Machine Translation better.

If you require additional information, please fill out our contact form.

Send us a message to chat about your needs or learn more about our services and pricing. We are always here for you—drop us a line to let us know how we can help. If you are looking to work for Lionbridge, please visit our "Join Our Team" page.

Let's Talk

Business Email Only

To find out how we process your personal information, consult our Privacy Policy.

Lionbridge Machine Translation Tracker

Comparing Four Machine Translation Deployment Strategies

Public MT

On-Premises MT

Cloud MT

Best-of-Breed MT

Which Automated Translation Engine Is Best?

Lionbridge Machine Translation Tracker Methodology

Lionbridge Expert Commentary

Never miss a thing.

Get Smarter About Automated Translation

Smart MT™: Machine Translation for the Digital Age

Lionbridge Language Cloud™: Is Machine Translation Getting Better?

How Lionbridge’s Automated Solution Enabled the Le Monde Newspaper to Boost Its Subscriber Count

Lionbridge Now Shares GPT-4 Machine Translation Results via Its Tracker

Language Ranking Based on Machine Translatability for More Effective MT

Machine Translation and Catastrophic Errors

Machine Translation and Formal vs. Informal Language

Using Terminology to Improve Machine Translation

Machine Translation Customization vs. Machine Translation Training

If you require additional information, please fill out our contact form.

Send us a message to chat about your needs or learn more about our services and pricing. We are always here for you—drop us a line to let us know how we can help. If you are looking to work for Lionbridge, please visit our "Join Our Team" page.

Let's Talk

WHAT WE DO

AI

INDUSTRIES

Lionbridge Machine Translation Tracker

Comparing Four Machine Translation Deployment Strategies

Public MT

On-Premises MT

Cloud MT

Best-of-Breed MT

Which Automated Translation Engine Is Best?

Lionbridge Machine Translation Tracker Methodology

Never miss a thing.

Get Smarter About Automated Translation

If you require additional information, please fill out our contact form.

Send us a message to chat about your needs or learn more about our services and pricing. We are always here for you—drop us a line to let us know how we can help. If you are looking to work for Lionbridge, please visit our "Join Our Team" page.

Let's Talk

INDUSTRIES